Sundarbans is the world’s largest and most diverse contiguous mangrove ecosystem. In this pilot study, three plots (around 1 ha each) were selected, where one site (S1) had 1 year of community involvement, another site (S2) had a community network to support the restoration initiatives for 2 years, while a control site (C) was devoid of any post plantation community protection. Rhizophora mucronata (Rhizophoraceae), Sonneretia caseolaris (Lythraceae) and Avicennia marina (Acanthaceae) were planted at the sites in 2012. After 6 years (in 2017), at S1, the monitoring showed low survival rate for salinity-sensitive species, 2% for R. mucronata and 4% for S. caseolaris. At S2, R. mucronata has high survival rates, i.e. 71%, followed by S. caseolaris with 40%, whereas at C, the survival rate of both species was 0%. At S1 and C, the salinity-tolerant A. marina replaced the planted mangroves partially (S1) or entirely (C). At S2, available soil P increased by 17.5%, in 6 years, and the overall blue carbon pool showed a linear increase from 64.4 to 88.6 Mg C ha−1 (34.3% rise). S1 showed a minimum increment in P and the blue carbon pool (6.9% rise), while site C showed fluctuations in the blue carbon pool with only a 3.1% increase. Humic acid and fulvic acid concentrations in the S2 site indicate positive functional carbon sequestration in the edaphic environment. The community involvement increased the plantation cost (567.70 USD) of S2, in comparison to S1 (342.52 USD) and C (117.34 USD), but it has resulted in better restoration and survival of the mangroves. The study concludes that community participation for at least 2 years can play a significant role in the conservation of mangrove ecosystems and the success of restoration initiatives in tidal, saline wetlands and would aid in compliance with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal 14 (Life Below Water) targets.