Judicial appointments, collegium system, and unresolved constitutional enigmas in India: Proposing an ‘emergency collegium’ and the ‘automatic elevation alternative’

Shrivastava, Anujay and Shrivastava, Abhijeet (2021) Judicial appointments, collegium system, and unresolved constitutional enigmas in India: Proposing an ‘emergency collegium’ and the ‘automatic elevation alternative’. Jus Corpus Law Journal, 1 (4). pp. 290-304. ISSN 25827820

[thumbnail of JCLJ2021.pdf]
JCLJ2021.pdf - Published Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial.

Download (485kB) | Preview


From the constitutional history of Judicial Appointments in India, it is well-known that the manner and procedure in which Judicial Appointments happen today, is starkly different from the original Judicial Appointments procedure contemplated under the Indian Constitution. Originally, Judicial Appointments to the Higher Judiciary (including appointments to the Supreme Court of India under Article 124 of the Constitution) were primarily the task of the Executive, where the Judiciary had no real say in the appointments to Higher Judiciary. This dynamic saw a stark shift after the Second Judges’ Case and subsequent precedents, which tilted the power dynamics around Judicial Appointments to Higher Judiciary (i.e. Supreme Court and various High Courts) in favour of the Supreme Court, and also established a ‘Collegium System’ to govern such Judicial Appointments. However, a Constitutional Enigma revolving around Judicial Appointments still persists. Should the Supreme Court be bereaved of most of its sitting Judges and the total strength of the court reduce to less than five sitting Judges, the Collegium propounded by the Third Judges’ Case would come to a collapse. If such a scenario arises in wake of calamities such as the devastating effects of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, how would Judicial Appointments to the Higher Judiciary be made? In this article, we seek to address this Constitutional Enigma, which is an unlikely but not an impossible or too remote a reality. We highlight the lacunae in the present judicially created law concerning Judicial Appointments. Moving forward, we propose the idea of an “Emergency Collegium” and lay out its modalities. Subsequently, we highlight an alternative of ‘automatic elevation’ of pan-India senior-most High Court Judges and also forward criticisms against such an alternative. Finally, we conclude by highlighting the necessity for a constitutional amendment or a ‘Fifth Judges’ Case’ to address this unresolved Constitutional Enigma.

Item Type: Article
Keywords: Automatic elevation | Appointment | Collegium | Constitution
Subjects: Social Sciences and humanities > Social Sciences > Law and Legal Studies
JGU School/Centre: Jindal Global Law School
Depositing User: Mr. Syed Anas
Date Deposited: 13 Feb 2022 10:43
Last Modified: 13 Feb 2022 13:09
Official URL: https://www.juscorpus.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/...
URI: https://pure.jgu.edu.in/id/eprint/1236


Downloads per month over past year

Actions (login required)

View Item
View Item